Banner Zone: Header Banner

Book Reviews

How to Knock a Bravebird from Her Perch

D.. Bryant Simmons
Bravebird Publishing, LLC
$17.95 hardback /
$17.95 paperback /
$8.99 e-book
334 pages
(Reviewer Rating)
(Average User Rating)
Back to book reviews
Reviewer: Melinda Holliday McDonald

TAGS: D. Bryant Simmons, Bravebird Publishing, Chicago, Illinois, domestic violence

How to Knock a Bravebird from Her Perch, the first novel in the Morrow Girls Series by D. Bryant Simmons, realistically explores the issues of domestic violence and the choices a young mother, with no financial resources of her own, must make.  

Belinda “Pecan” Morrow is a small-town good girl who is being raised by a single father.  Ricky Morrow arrives into town from Biloxi with dreams of becoming the next great boxer.  Pecan is shocked when the handsome muscular newcomer focuses his attention on her.  Ricky tells Pecan she is going to be his girl and they quickly become a hot item.  Soon thereafter, Pecan’s father unexpectedly dies and she is heartbroken and declares that she is now all alone.  Ricky reassures Pecan she has him, and vows to take care of her.  By the end of the week, she is a married woman.  It isn’t long before Pecan realizes she made a huge mistake marrying Ricky.

The novel immediately jumps into Pecan’s new life in Chicago as a wife and a mother of a three year-old.  The author provides cursory insight into what Pecan’s life was like over the course of the three years leading up to her decision to try and leave the first time Ricky hit her.  While it becomes quickly apparent that Pecan is plagued with grief over her father’s death during that time, and one day admits to herself that she doesn’t love Ricky, it isn’t clear what (if there was one) the catalyst moment is that motivates Pecan try to leave that first time.  Is she just unhappy? Is she unfilled? Does she hate Chicago? Is she already being beaten and raped? The reader is left to his or own reasoning in making sense of Pecan’s decision to pack her and her child’s few belongings in small plastic bags, without a real plan.  The reader is also left to surmise whether or not the day Pecan tries to leave is the first time Ricky hits her.  Typically, domestic violence is not sudden;  it would have been helpful to know what signs of abuse were present during those three years, which Pecan ignored.  Pecan alludes to them, but they are never spelled out.    While the author admittedly acknowledges that her preferred writing style is to jump right into the meat, the consequence is that the novel fails to immediately grab the reader’s emotions and tie them into Pecan’s story early on.

Most of the novel is dedicated to Pecan’s failed attempts at protecting herself and her girls from Ricky, until she finally finds the strength to fight back and unknowingly delivers a fatal blow.  In that respect the novel lacks anything uplifting, and is just one paragraph after another of a woman feeling and acting helpless until she unknowingly kills her abuser, and is finally free.  

Bravebird moves along at a steady pace, but reading about domestic violence does not make for light reading. There aren’t many dull moments or long, irrelevant paragraphs, and  every word in the novel serves a purpose and allows the story to move well.   Nonetheless, if the subject matter itself isn’t an immediate turn-off, How to Knock a Bravebird from Her Perch is a good quick read with sufficient detail and grit to make it a page turner. 


Melinda Holliday McDonald, Esq. is an attorney with the federal government, specializing in employee and personnel law and privacy law.  She is currently writing a book chronicling her efforts to become a mother through IVF and natural conception, after the death of her adopted son.  She is an avid reader and a 10+ year member of a local bookclub – Unique Women Only (UWO).  A graduate of Georgetown University and George Washington University Law School, she is currently married with two living children (one deceased) and two dogs in Maryland.


Your Comments:
Your Name:
Your Book Rating:

I read this book also & found that the lack of detail in the actual abuse made you focus more on the struggles that one goes through when they are involved with a person that is an abuser. Just another perspective on that because in the beginning I also questioned that lack of detail but as I continued to read I found that I ultimately was more interested in how Pecan handled things & the challenges she faced. I thought it was a good look into the minds of most women in a scenario such as hers. How they think and act, what they face, how they are the victims of many... including themselves. I'm enjoying the reveiws from others, it's nice to see what people get out of the book & all seem to agree that while the topic is one that isn't very light, it's definitely a great read.

Comment by: Melanie (
User Rating: 4

Thanks to Melinda for taking the time to read and review Bravebird. Unfortunately, there are some factual errors in this review. In chapter one (page 16 in the paperback version), Pecan says, "even though he never hit me before then I knew that if I even looked at the door he'd make his move." So, he never hit her before then. The first time that she tries to leave Ricky is the first time he hits her. You can read this chapter for free on my website ( You'll also find in chapter one (pages 12 and 13 in the paperback version) Pecan's reasoning for deciding to leave Ricky. Maybe her reasons seem illegitimate to some and that's fine. To each his own. But the reasons are there nevertheless. Also, her daughter is two years old not three when she decides to leave Ricky. Again, I thank Melinda for taking the time to review my beloved Bravebird :) It's not for everyone. No harm in that. Domestic violence is a difficult topic to write and read about, especially when the focus is on being realistic (as this review points out). At times I didn't want to go there myself but Pecan's story needed to be told and I hope that it inspires people to think twice before judging women in violent relationships. As a society, we have a tendency to want to blame the victim. Why didn't she stop it? Why didn't she do this or do that? Well, in a perfect world (with perfect people) obviously she would have or perhaps she wouldn't have had to because domestic violence wouldn't exist. Instead let us consider that women need not be perfect to escape domestic abuse. That every woman, regardless of her faults, issues, or handicaps is entitled to a happy peaceful life. That responsibility for the abuse should not lie at her feet but her abuser's. And let us remember that strong women take many forms and no woman is 100% safe from domestic abuse. It doesn't only happen to the weakest of us. It can happen to any of us.

Comment by: D. Bryant Simmons
User Rating: 5

© 2015 - The Black Book Review Online. All Rights Reserved. Powered by VSM.